Welcome to Coastal Pizza
Coastal Pizza, located in the heart of Fernandina Beach, FL, is a culinary gem that captures the essence of coastal dining. Known for its thin, crispy crusts and flavorful toppings, this pizzeria consistently impresses diners. Highlights include the fan-favorite Tom's Fave pizza and delicious garlic knots, which have garnered rave reviews from customers. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make every visit memorable. Whether you’re grabbing a quick takeout or enjoying a meal in-house, the joy of Coastal Pizza lies not just in its delectable menu but also in the communal spirit that thrives among staff and guests alike.
Coastal Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
I love everything! My special favorite is Tom’s Fave pizza. The garlic knots are great and one of these days I’ll have the Veal Parmesan dinner which a pal of mine swears by.
I came in on Sunday to do a quick takeout order and ended up staying for a couple beers. The service, atmosphere and food were phenomenal. They really know how to treat people there. I will definitely be returning the next time I visit Fernandina Beach (from Jax)! Very memorable place and the staff seems happy to be there. I had the Margherita pizza. So good
This is the best pizza that I have found on the island. Thin crisp crust, flavorful sauce and toppings. This place is always busy - for good reason.
Visiting a friend and our host picked up two pies for dinner tonight. I ordered the mushrooms, jalapenos, & Bell Peppers. Great crispy crust and plenty of toppings. The girls had half mushroom and half pepperoni. Truly great !!!
Dropped by on Saturday evening. Had a staff member at the hotel I was staying at recommend this place. Did not disappoint. Service was excellent, friendly staff, quick turn around on my carry out order. The food was delicious, especially the garlic knots. Will definitely be back!
Went by reviews. Did not disappoint. Cozy and busy. Lasagna was very good. Garlic cheese bread and bread knots were also good. My husband got the BRC (bacon, ranch, chicken) pizza. He said was good. Thick crust. Very good server. Very good Greek salad. If you like a light beer, highly recommend Landshark.
In town visiting my mom again, surprise mother's Day visit.... While she was working I grabbed lunch...I got the on-point cheesy meatball stuffed mushrooms, a Green Point Coffee beer, and a 10 in Margerita pizza with pepperoni n sausage added...(Recommended by guy sitting next to me .). The pizza was nothing short of spectacular combo of fresh, savory, and spicy n and the perfect amount of fresh tomatoes.... Besides the food the atmosphere is relaxing even when busy...service is impeccable and even got a few ideas for places to take my mother for a fancy dinner... Check it out n make sure you ask about the specials...they are very creative and you can tell the chef cooks with passion!!!
Not too busy when we went about 6 pm. I got the 10" beach access 7 without cheese and I was full when I finished it. Fabulous server- for personality. I didn't feel like "just another table". The pizza was probably the best I've had this year. Especially for the price. We also had wings and fried pickles for the table and those were also great! I definitely could have compared those wings to Wing Maxx or Zaxby's. Crispy, decent size, good flavor- I was very satisfied with my experience there and think I might go back there next time I'm in the area.
Location
-
1916 S 14th St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034, United States Hotline: +1 904-491-9998
Welcome to Coastal Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Fernandina Beach, Florida. Located at 1916 S 14th St, this vibrant eatery offers a delightful balance of flavor and atmosphere that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for more. Whether you're toasting with friends over a pint or sharing a hearty meal with family, Coastal Pizza delivers an experience that is nothing short of extraordinary.
From the moment you step inside, the friendly staff greets you with genuine warmth, setting the tone for a memorable dining experience. Patrons rave about the impeccable service and inviting ambiance, making it a perfect spot for both a quick takeout and a leisurely meal. Various customers have shared their appreciation for the attentive team and the lively atmosphere, indicating that Coastal Pizza knows how to make guests feel right at home.
The pizza here is a true standout. Reviewers tout the thin, crisp crust paired with a flavorful sauce and generous toppings that cater to every palate. Janet, a loyal customer, particularly loves Tom’s Fave pizza, while others have praised the classic Margherita for its simplicity and freshness. With options ranging from hearty pepperoni to a mix of mushrooms, jalapeños, and bell peppers, there is something for everyone to savor. Each bite tells a story of culinary craftsmanship, ensuring that your pizza cravings are met with both quality and taste.
Then, of course, there are the garlic knots — a beloved side that has gained a reputation of its own. Many diners agree that these little doughy delights are a must-try, perfectly seasoned and fluffy, making them an ideal companion to any pizza order. E M describes Coastal Pizza as the best on the island, a sentiment echoed by many who have tasted their exceptional offerings.
But the experience doesn't stop at pizza; you might also want to indulge in their Veal Parmesan dinner, recommended by customers raving about its rich flavors and generous portions. It’s clear that Coastal Pizza is more than just a pizza place—it's a destination where culinary passion meets community charm. Whether you're a local or just passing through, your visit to Coastal Pizza will undoubtedly be a highlight of your culinary journey in Fernandina Beach.
So why wait? Stop by or call +1 904-491-9998 and treat yourself to a delicious meal at Coastal Pizza. You won't regret it!